Key Points Compared to controls, WBCT scans of hallux valgus (HV) & hallux rigidus (HR)…
- Researchers from RNOH Stanmore analyzed 182 feet via WBCT to define normal values for 1st MT rotation.
- Normal range is be between -5 and 16 degrees for the MPA and – 4 and 18 degrees for the α angle.
- In general, most patients have a “constitutional, mild metatarsal pronation.”
The recognized importance first metatarsal rotational profile for optimal assessment of hallux valgus is rising among foot & ankle specialists. However, normal values for metatarsal rotation as observed on weight bearing CT (WBCT) remain undefined. Ali-Asgar Najefi, FRCS, et al, at the Foot and Ankle Unit at the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust in Stanmore, Middlesex, UK, analyzed 182 feet (the largest study size known to date) to determine what a normal range may be for patients without hallux valgus deformities.
Researchers used images captured from a CurveBeam pedCAT WBCT system to calculate metatarsal pronation angle (MPA) and the α angle, techniques that measure the rotation of the metatarsal head independent of the position of the sesamoids. Patients with abnormal hallux valgus angle (HVA) and intermetatarsal angle (IMA) measurements were excluded from the cohort.
Access the full study here.
Unlike previous studies, researchers exclusively used WBCT studies. Measurements were calculated from digitally reconstructed radiographs that were generated from the 3D volumes.
Researchers found the “normal” range to be between between -5 and 16 degrees for the MPA and between -4 and 18 degrees for the α angle. There was no significant differences in both angles between males and females despite a significantly higher hallux valgus angle (HVA) in female patients, and no relationship at all was found based on age. The reliability for interobserver for the MPA and α angle was good (0.83 and 0.80, respectively) and for the intraobserver it was excellent (0.95 and 0.97 respectively).
In general, researchers concluded most patients have a “constitutional, mild metatarsal pronation.” The study results suggested that as the hindfoot goes into valgus, there is a greater pronation of the metatarsal.
Single coronal slices were used, oriented parallel to the floor in the coronal plane and along the axis of the first metatarsal in the sagittal plane. These images were then reoriented in the axial plane to align with the long axis of the third metatarsal, and a perpendicular line to this that bisected the sesamoids was chosen as the specific coronal slice for the two measurements.
To measure the α angle, an inferior line was drawn between the lateral edge of the lateral sulcus and the medial edge of the medial sulcus, and a superior line was drawn between the point of the medial and lateral corners of the first metatarsal head. Bisections of these 2 lines were connected to a straight line perpendicular to the horizontal ground axis, and the α angle was measured between them.
To measure the MPA, a line was drawn connecting the most inferomedial border of the medial sesamoid facet and the most lateral border of the later sesamoid facet. Another line was drawn along the weight bearing surface (the floor). The angle between these lines was measured. For both angles, pronation was recorded as positive.
Researchers said additional work is needed to determine if correcting for rotation in hallux valgus surgery leads to lower recurrence rates and higher patient satisfaction.